As the ending credits roled for the latest summer blockbuster, Cowboys & Aliens, I sat in the theater with my buddy and tried to grasp what it was we just saw. After a few quiet minutes, we looked at each other and just shrugged. John Favreau’s (Iron Man, Iron Man 2) latest creation is an interesting melding of the Western and Sci-fi genres. At no point does the film go campy which was a surprising relief, and it does a competent job at telling a story of western settlers, outlaws and natives teaming up to defeat the unknown demons who threaten to eradicate their existence.
The standout in this film is Daniel Craig, who gives an intense performance as the brooding and enigmatic Jake Lonergan, an outlaw who can’t remember his painful past. Harrison Ford’s portrayal as Woodrow Dolarhyde, a rich, ruthless cattle owner, offers the audience an unusual departure from Ford’s typical typecast as the suave, leading man hero. Sam Rockwell’s inclusion into this cast was an exciting surprise as I saw his name in the opening credits. However I found myself disappointed at how meek and submissive his character was in the film. I don’t think they best utilized his outstanding acting talents.
My biggest disappointment surrounded Olivia Wilde’s performance as Elle Swenson. For the first half of the film it seemed her main purpose was just to stand in the shot, look pretty and give varying levels of vacant stares. It was if she was channeling her inner Megan Fox. Then the storyline takes a strange and kind of clunky shift (I won’t go into details for I don’t want to ruin the surprise for you) and suddenly her character adds a completely different annoyance level to the film. Her role felt a bit contrived and artificial to me; perhaps an actress with a bit more range might have been better suited for the character.
When trying to describe Cowboys & Aliens, my buddy put it best when he said that it was an alien movie with a western setting. And that left me a bit disheartened. I found the most enjoyable parts in this film were the true western scenes when the aliens weren’t around to muck it up. There is an excellent movie buried somewhere in this big, explosive summer blockbuster. With the success of last year’s True Grit, I would love to see this film redone as a true western. Even still, Cowboys & Aliens does have a certain entertainment value, and I give it credit for not completely falling on its face. (3 out of 5 stars)
(Just for future reference, I have decided to switch to a 5 star system because I feel it gives me more flexibility in my ratings)












